David Harold "Digger" Freay, 76, of Mayville passed away on Tuesday, November 17, 2026 at the Heritage Green Skilled Nursing and Rehabilitation Center in Greenhurst, following a lengthy illness. He was born on March 29, 1950 in Jamestown, the son of the late Harold Leonard and Frances Arnold Freay.
Dave was a 1968 graduate of Mayville Central School and then attended the Simmons School of Mortuary Science in Syracuse, where he earned an Associate's degree in mortuary science and embalming. Shortly after, at the age of 22, he became the owner of the Barber Funeral Home in Westfield, which he operated from 1973-1983. At that time, he was the youngest person in New York State to own and operate his own funeral home -- a distinction of which he was very proud. In 1983, he purchased the Freay Funeral Home in Mayville from his father, which he operated until his retirement in 2017, completing a 43-year career as a licensed funeral director. Throughout those years, he cared for countless families in their most difficult moments with kindness, patience, and respect.
Dave was a past board member and president of the Village of Mayville Zoning Board. For 18 years, he was a member of the Mayville Fire Department, where he served as an EMT, and a member of the Chautauqua Golf Club. He played in the Bill Sprague Memorial Golf League for over 40 years.
Dave enjoyed hunting, fishing, golfing, bowling, rooting for the Buffalo Bills, and spending time with friends and family. He was a true do-it-yourself kind of guy who loved working on projects at the funeral home and at his home on Hannum Road, where he later retired.
Dave is survived by his loving wife, Deborah Jane Reffner Freay, whom he married on July 20, 1974; his three children, James (Abbey Flaherty) Freay, Andrew (Elizabeth) Freay and Mary Jane (Douglas) Bordenkircher, all of Mayville; his 10 grandchildren, Robin, Isaac, Nora, Maggie, Molly, Grace, Shannon, Rory, Olivia and Elliot; his four sisters, Deborah (Gregory) Edwards of Jamestown, Jane Loewer of Westfield, Brenda (Peter) Holl of Mayville and Cindy Freay of Portland; and numerous nieces and nephews. In addition to his parents, he was preceded in death by several aunts and uncles.
He will be deeply missed and lovingly remembered by all who knew him.
The family will receive friends on Monday, November 23 from 4:00-7:00 PM at Freay Funeral Home, 139 South Erie Street in Mayville. The funeral service will be private, with the Rev. Cathy Smith officiating. Burial will be in the Mayville Cemetery.
Memorial donations may be made to the North Lake Rescue Squad, PO Box 2, Mayville, NY 14757.
To leave a remembrance or post condolences to the family, please visit www.freayfuneralhome.com.